CareToLive Reports Forbes Journalist to the SEC for “Rumor Mongering”

CareToLive, a not for profit corporation, wrote to Steve Forbes and his editors last Tuesday, asking them to investigate Matthew Herper and to consider relieving him of his duties. CareToLive cited Mr. Herper’s one-sided, rumor mongering story, which will appear in the September 15th issue of Forbes magazine. CareToLive presented the real story and tied it in to a Forbes welcoming screen, which displayed the following quote:

“Every being must desire happiness for himself.”

-Richard Price

CareToLive informed Steve Forbes that although Forbe’s use of the above quote is a nice idea, as long as people like Mr. Herper interfere with that desire for happiness, namely the happiness of the 96,000 men desiring a safe, non-toxic treatment for their late stage prostate cancer, it only remains a nice idea.

CareToLive relayed to Mr. Forbes that it should report Matthew Herper to the SEC for rumor mongering, in part because of his use of the word “lousy” when describing the Provenge data. Writing that the data were lousy demonstrated his own bias as the word lousy never appeared in any of the three leaked letters that he was referencing. SEC Chairman Christopher Cox said that the new enforcement action for rumor mongering cracks down on rumors that the disseminator knows to be false.

Furthermore, CareToLive informed Mr. Herper prior to the article that CareToLive was just coming into existence at the time of the Chicago rally and was not responsible for organizing it. Regardless, the Chicago rally was completely peaceful, and there were no threats or intimidation leveled from the demonstrators, all of whom conducted themselves in a dignified, professional manner.

CareToLive does not try to alienate or antagonize the many thousands of practicing oncologists. Our only problem has been with the five conflicted oncologists that worked to stop the Provenge license approval, namely Howard Scher, Maha Hussain, Thomas Fleming, Richard Pazdur and Alison Martin. CareToLive informed Mr. Forbes that there are prominent cancer doctors who firmly believe in the Provenge data, and await the approval of the treatment so they may administer it to their patients suffering from late stage prostate cancer.

CareToLive waited for a response from Forbes, without success, and two days later sent notice of the rumor mongering to Enforcement at the SEC. Once again CTL laid out the story, this time covering many of Scher’s conflicts, in particular the fact that Scher publicly admitted on page 3 of his leaked letter that he was leading a Phase III trial for a Provenge competitor. CareToLive believes that Scher should have excused himself from serving and voting on the Provenge Advisory Committee due to his lack of impartiality. CareToLive asked the SEC to investigate Dr. Scher’s conflicts and included the details of Scher’s ProQuest Investments Scientific Advisory position, and his relationship with Novacea.

When this article hits the newsstands any day now, and appears in subscribers’ mailboxes, or in waiting rooms of doctors and dentists, Mr. Herper will have achieved his goal of wrongly influencing the readers.

All of this was CC’d to Steve Forbes, his editors and Mr. Herper so they could see, once again, the other side of the story and to try to encourage Mr. Herper to be objective when he writes his next story on Dendreon and CareToLive. The SEC acknowledged receipt of the complaint.

CareToLive feels the article was in part penned by Mr. Herper out of revenge since CareToLive’s lawyer questioned Mr. Herper’s previous article. It is also CareToLive’s belief that Mr. Herper has never been fair to Provenge in his coverage of this prostate cancer immunotherapy and that Mr. Herper was the first to leak parts of Maha Hussain’s letter, the day before it was officially published.

For more information go to www.CareToLive.com

Popularity: 33%

Tags: cancer, CareToLive, Dendreon, FDA, Fleming, Forbes, Herper, Hussain, Pazdur, prostate, provenge, scher

This entry was posted on Monday, September 8th, 2008 at 5:13 pm and is filed under The Cause. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.