CareToLive RSS
Subscribe to the CareToLive RSS feed for up to date news and developments surrounding the legal battle against the FDA and more. (RSS feed reader required)
Subscribe to the CareToLive RSS feed for up to date news and developments surrounding the legal battle against the FDA and more. (RSS feed reader required)
Spread The Word
Please help spread the word about CareToLive. Any of the information found on this website can be distributed and shared freely. We only ask that you provide a link back to this website if you publish our content.
Please help spread the word about CareToLive. Any of the information found on this website can be distributed and shared freely. We only ask that you provide a link back to this website if you publish our content.
Donations
CareToLive is a not for profit corporation; however, donations are NOT tax exempt.
CareToLive is a not for profit corporation; however, donations are NOT tax exempt.
Posts by kdonahue
Provenge is approved!
- Provenge has been approved! Thank you to all who helped achieve this important milestone for cancer patients.
LATEST POSTS
- 11/27/2011 - Care To Live Board Member Ted Girgus Dies of Prostate Cancer
- 09/06/2011 - Care To Live Update on SEC OIG Investigation into April 28, 2009 Dendreon Bear Raid
- 07/13/2011 - 3 Minute Video Explaining Provenge Treatment
- 06/20/2011 - Abigail Alliance Plans FDA PROTEST June 28
- 06/09/2011 - RIP Charles A. Reinwald — Cancer Cure Coalition Founder
- 04/29/2011 - Care To Live Submits Moment of Silence to CMS
- 04/28/2011 - HHS Desperately Needs Transparency Lessons From CMS
- 04/23/2011 - Please Post for Provenge!
- 04/19/2011 - Another Interim Provenge Prostate Cancer Immunotherapy CMS FOIA Response
- 04/16/2011 - PROVENGE! PROVENGE! GET YOUR PROVENGE HERE!
MOST POPULAR
- Setting the Record Straight
- Provenge Is Approved But The Lies Continue
- Provenge Works & Costs the Same as Chemo & Comments by Bishop
- The Bloodshed, Bogus Threats, Birth Defects, Bashers Cover Letter
- PROVENGE WILL BE COVERED BY MEDICARE
- CareToLive sends a Freedom of Information Request to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
- ASCO Tells CMS It Should Cover Provenge
- The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services are requesting comments.
- Dr. Snuffy Myers Advocates For Provenge Treatment
- Senators Specter and Kerry - CMS Has Some 'Splaining To Do
WHATS GOING ON
This Is An Emergency!
We rallied outside the FDA building in Rockville, Maryland on September 18th. Now there are buses riding around Rockville and Washington, D.C., further protesting the shenanigans that took place inside the FDA building, as well as outside.
The FDA has gotten caught up with Wall Street. While it is supposed to be busy with evaluating food and drugs, its employees just can't keep their eyes off the money. So that is how decisions are being made these days.
This Is An Emergency!
We rallied outside the FDA building in Rockville, Maryland on September 18th. Now there are buses riding around Rockville and Washington, D.C., further protesting the shenanigans that took place inside the FDA building, as well as outside.
The FDA has gotten caught up with Wall Street. While it is supposed to be busy with evaluating food and drugs, its employees just can't keep their eyes off the money. So that is how decisions are being made these days.
WE'LL BE BACK
These people traveled from all across the country to protest outside the FDA Building in Rockville, Maryland. The FDA has stopped a safe and effective treatment from getting to men who need it now. The treatment is called Provenge and it treats men who have late stage prostate cancer.
The FDA appointed a panel of experts to help it decide on the safety and efficacy of Provenge. That panel voted 17-0 that Provenge was safe. And it voted 13-4 that Provenge showed substantial evidence it worked. And yet the FDA delayed it. Now it could be a year, a year and a half or it could be three years. It could be forever.
These people will keeping coming back to Rockville and they hope others will join them until the courts, the FDA, Congress or somebody does something about this travesty.
These people traveled from all across the country to protest outside the FDA Building in Rockville, Maryland. The FDA has stopped a safe and effective treatment from getting to men who need it now. The treatment is called Provenge and it treats men who have late stage prostate cancer.
The FDA appointed a panel of experts to help it decide on the safety and efficacy of Provenge. That panel voted 17-0 that Provenge was safe. And it voted 13-4 that Provenge showed substantial evidence it worked. And yet the FDA delayed it. Now it could be a year, a year and a half or it could be three years. It could be forever.
These people will keeping coming back to Rockville and they hope others will join them until the courts, the FDA, Congress or somebody does something about this travesty.

FDA Trifecta — Gottlieb Calls Em Out, Miller Rallies on the Rail, Hamburg Limps Lamely to Finish
January 16th, 2011 | Posted by Kerry Donahueby Kerry M. Donahue
FDA commissioner Margaret Hamburg recently defended the FDA against criticisms leveled by former FDA Deputy Commissioner Dr. Scott Gottlieb and Hoover Institute fellow Henry Miller. She took issue with the idea that the FDA is not following the mandates of Congress to get safe and effective new treatments to patients in a timely way, particularly late stage patients with few, if any, viable alternatives.
Of course those who followed the Provenge approval process with CareToLive understand that FDA figurehead Hamburg is baffled, befuddled and completely out of touch with the reality of the situation. Ms. Hamburg needs to look no further than the case of Provenge and the now 15 other effective treatments for late stage diseases that heroes like Frank Burroughs at the Abigail Alliance http://abigail-alliance.org/ supported, and which were all eventually approved for treatment of life threatening diseases. Unfortunately not before hundreds of thousands of patients died, sometimes from terrible and painful diseases, without ever having been able to obtain these treatments.
The fault lies squarely with the FDA process and their failure to prioritize and accelerate review as demanded by Congress, and by humanity itself. Continue Reading FDA Trifecta — Gottlieb Calls Em Out, Miller Rallies on the Rail, Hamburg Limps Lamely to Finish »
Popularity: 15%
Tags: abigail alliance, Dendreon, FDA, Frank Burroughs, Henry Miller, Immunotherapy, Kerry M. Donahue, Margaret Hamburg, Prostate Cancer, provenge, Scott Gottlieb
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA, The Lawsuit | 1 Comment »
Care To Live Attorney Kerry M. Donahue Argues for Pazdur’s Deleted Documents
December 9th, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueI prepared for orals expecting a lot of questions. There were not many questions asked by Judge Norris or Judge Martin but quite a few by Judge Cook. Judge Norris and Martin are a couple of salty old dogs and seem a bit more lighthearted then many of their stiffer brethren.
I had 15 minutes, 5 of which I saved for rebuttal. I presented the issue and spoke about how this case was different then most FOIA cases in that we know that there were, and maybe still are, requested documents on the computer of a single individual at the FDA.
We know this by virtue of Richard Pazdur’s admittance that he had the documents on his computer but he deleted them. So in this case the CDER division of the FDA knows where to look. Continue Reading Care To Live Attorney Kerry M. Donahue Argues for Pazdur’s Deleted Documents »
Popularity: 15%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, CDER, Dendreon, DOJ, FDA, Immunotherapy, Kerry M. Donahue, Prostate Cancer, provenge, Richard Pazdur
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA | 1 Comment »
Dr. Snuffy Myers Advocates For Provenge Treatment
May 20th, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueDr. Myers’s thoughts on Provenge.
http://askdrmyers.wordpress.com/2010/07/07/provenge-case-study/ (video)
About Dr. Snuffy Myers http://askdrmyers.wordpress.com/about/
With over 250 research papers published, Myers is one of the leading developers of today’s prostate cancer canon on both the research and treatment side of the test tube. Prostate Forum is the educational arm of his world-renowned practice that is dedicated to providing men with the comprehensive care that saved his own life.
Care To Live friend M.C. Lee summed it up.
- Longer survival
- Less side effect
- Comparable cost
- Productive life
M. C. Lee Edit: Forgot that demand will definitely outstrip supply in the FORESEEABLE future. So if you want it you better bug your doctor about it.
Popularity: 76%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, Dendreon, Dr. Snuffy Myers, Prostate Cancer, provenge. Kerry M. Donahue
Posted in The Cause | Post a Comment »
The Real Provenge Story
May 3rd, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueThe real story—the tragedy in this case, and the one yet to be told by the so-called “Mainstream Media”—is the story of the needless three-year delay in availability of Dendreon’s Provenge for our sons, fathers, and grandfathers.
The Dendreon Investor Village (IV) message board at www.investorvillage.com(link) is where a group of the most well-informed people in the world on all-things-Dendreon, exchange information. Many have posted there non-stop since early in the decade. One daily post entitled “Daily Death Count”, documents the number of men who have died of prostate cancer since “Black Wednesday” (link to Mark Thornton op ed), May 8, 2007, the date the FDA went against the recommendation of its own Advisory Committee and refused to approve Provenge. As of this past Thursday, the date Provenge received final approval, the death count stood at 90,055. Every one of these 90,055 men were deeply loved and now dearly missed by their families and friends.
It’s difficult to ignore the fact that the March 29, 2007 Provenge Advisory Committee voted unanimously (17-0) that the drug is SAFE, or the fact that the same Committee voted minutes later, (13-4) that the drug “demonstrated substantial evidence of efficacy,” the federally mandated standard in such reviews. But the FDA did. The FDA also ignored the fact that the treatment was being submitted to help men with end stage prostate cancer, the stage for which there is no viable treatment option. Provenge would have been their last resort. Continue Reading The Real Provenge Story »
Popularity: 50%
Tags: , Andrew Von Eschenbach, Care To Live, CareToLive, CBER, CDER, Dendreon, FDA, Kerry M. Donahue, Prostate Cancer, provenge
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA | Post a Comment »
Ohio Congressman Tiberi Stays After FDA
April 6th, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueThe honorable Pat Tiberi, House Representative from the 12th District of Ohio, refuses to accept a brush off by the FDA.
Representative Tiberi continues to doggedly pursue answers from the FDA as to why the ongoing delay of Provenge for late stage prostate cancer patients, continues without excuse.
Tiberii is a true Patriot, seeking answers for the men needlessly waiting on the dysfunctional FDA to do its job.
See his second recent inquiry to the FDA here (click below to enlarge) or download here pattiberi02.pdf
Popularity: 9%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, FDA, Pat Tiberi, Prostate Cancer Dendreon, provenge
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA | Post a Comment »
Now Public - CBER Gone Fishing While Men Gone Wishing
January 8th, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueFDA’s CBER Gone Fishing While Men Gone Wishing
Read it here http://www.nowpublic.com/health/fdas-cber-gone-fishing-while-men-gone-wishing
Popularity: 12%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, CBER, CDER, Denreon, FDA, Jesse Goodman, Kerry M. Donahue, Prostate Cancer, provenge
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA | Post a Comment »
CareToLive Attorney Kerry Donahue’s Op-Ed Published on Now Public — Men Don’t Have the Luxury of Waiting
January 2nd, 2010 | Posted by Kerry DonahueFDA’S Cber Sipping New Year’s Champagne Burst Patient’s Bubbles
http://my.nowpublic.com/health/fdas-cber-sipping-new-years-champagne-burst-patients-bubbles
Popularity: 12%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, CBER, CDER, Dendreon, FDA, Kerry M. Donhahue, NowPublic, Prostate Cancer, provenge
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA | Post a Comment »
American Hold ‘Em
August 13th, 2009 | Posted by Kerry DonahueHold the deck.
On the other hand:
That the Provenge BLA was not afforded proper due process is an absolute. Because it clearly was not afforded proper due process nobody can say with any certainty that the FDA made a reasonable decision. Once the process is corrupted it’s all guesswork from there. Nobody knows for sure the extent of influences and back room shenanigans that occurred to assure that Provenge was not fairly evaluated. When CareToLive through litigation and FOIA’s tried to get information they were stymied by the FDA who went to great lengths to avoid any transparency on the issue.
There are aces scattered all over the floor at the FDA and a couple sticking out of a few sleeves so how can the game have been fairly played? Is it too much to ask for a fair game? The denial of a fair PROCESS is the one truth that the FDA could have, should have, admitted.
If that process occurred in a court room there would, at a minimum, have been declared a mistrial, when the evidence of such became known (which was made known to the FDA by petition, litigation and of course lots of letters).
That they did not make a reasonable and common sense decision based on the class of patients for which Provenge was seeking approval, or conduct a proper risk/benefit analysis with a focus on the fact that the treatment was destined for late stage patients is clear.
The FDA said two things that support this; One was that the minority voices on the AC panel were taken into consideration as a factor in the decision making process, and Two is that Richard Pazdur of CDER influenced that process. Top that off with an FDA commissioner who just happens to be a very good friend of Milken……
I don’t want the point to be lost that it is the position of CareToLive that there is no way anyone can say a reasonable decision was made, because the process was completely corrupted. CareToLive has sought accountability and transparency to determine in what ways the process fell short. If the FDA would show us the process then we might be persuaded otherwise. Until then and even because of the cover up itself, it has to be evaluated based on what we know.
The cover up and the lack of transparency is indicative that the FDA made a choice that transparency would make matters worse in this case. Otherwise, why fight so hard to keep the process from the public eye.
What other influences entered into the picture. Political pressure? Milken pressure? Financial pressure? Inside power struggles? Some or all of the above?
The deck was stacked. The dice were loaded. Everybody knows!
With all that you now know about Milken and the depths of his depravity, does it not trouble you that he had considerable control and influence over at least Scher, Martin and von Eschenbach if not others? Continue Reading American Hold ‘Em »
Popularity: 15%
Tags: Alison Martin, Andrew Von Eschenbach, BLA, Care To Live, CareToLive, CBER, CDER, Deep Capture, DeepCapture.com, Dendreon, FDA, Howard Scher, Kerry Donahue, maha hussain, Mark Mitchell, Michael Milken, PCF, Prostate Cancer, Prostate Cancer Foundation, provenge, Richard Pazdur
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA, The Lawsuit | Post a Comment »
CareToLive Files Response to FDA in Freedom of Information Case - We Want Discovery!
June 16th, 2009 | Posted by Kerry DonahueCareToLive Attorney Kerry Donahue filed Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant’s Memorandum in Opposition Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to Conduct Discovery Under Civil Rule 56(f)
You can read the response here >> Response for Discovery
See Exhibit A >> exhibit-a-061609.pdf
See Exhibit B >> exhibit-b-061609.pdf
See Exhibit C* >> exhibitc.pdf
*Exhibit C — Taken from Demystifying Computer Forensics written by Johnette Hassell, Ph.D. and Susan Steen
CareToLive would like to thank the authors who were kind enough to let us use excerpts from their document — demystifying-computer-forensics.pdf . Johnette Hassell and Susan Steen are partners in Electronic Evidence Retrieval, L.L.C., a company specializing in computer forensics and other expert consultation and testimony in computer science. They have more than twenty years of experience in computer consultation and testimony, computer forensics, software and technical manual copyright infringement support, and programmatic research and evaluation. They can be reached at info@ElectronicEvidenceRetrieval.com or 504.483.0201 on the Gulf Coast and 970.922.7250 in the Rocky Mountain area. http://www.electronicevidenceretrieval.com/
Popularity: 14%
Tags: Andrew Von Eschenbach, Care To Live, CareToLive, Dendreon, DOJ, Electronic Evidence Retrieval, FDA, Howard Scher, Johnette Hassell, Kerry Donahue, maha hussain, Prostate Cancer, provenge, Richard Pazdur, Rick Pazdur, Susan Steen
Posted in The Cause, The Dysfunctional FDA, The Lawsuit | Post a Comment »
CareToLive Files For Access to FDA Pazdur’s CDER Hard Drive
June 6th, 2009 | Posted by Kerry DonahueMOTION FOR LEAVE TO CONDUCT/COMPLETE DISCOVERY UNDER CIVIL RULE 56(f)
AND PARTIAL MEMORANDUM CONTRA TO DEFENDANT FDA’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Now Comes Plaintiff, CareToLive, on behalf of its members and all suffering late stage prostate cancer patients and their families who have now been denied a proven safe and effective treatment for over two years and request leave from this Court to conduct a limited amount of discovery so as to more fully respond to the Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant, as further set forth in the attached memorandum.
Link to Motion >> ctlfoiaresponse6-06-09c.pdf
Popularity: 15%
Tags: Care To Live, CareToLive, CBER, CDER, Dendreon, FDA, Hamburg, HHS, Howard Scher, Immunotherapy, Kerry Donahue, maha hussain, Prostate Cancer, provenge, Richard Pazdur, Thomas R Fleming
Posted in The Dysfunctional FDA, The Lawsuit | Post a Comment »